[Goanet-News] NEWS: Indian newspapers fall for baroque Nazi war criminal hoax

[Goanet News]

http://blogs.reuters.com/india/2008/06/30/indian-newspapers-fall-for-baroque-nazi-war-criminal-hoax/

June 30th, 2008
Indian newspapers fall for baroque Nazi war criminal hoax
Post a comment (5)
Posted by: Jonathan Allen
Tags: Critical Eye, hoaxes, India, media

You would think a press release about a German Nazi war criminal named
Johann Bach being caught in the jungles of Goa after trying to sell a
stolen 18th-century piano would be worth double-checking.

A reconstruction of the head of 18th-century German composer Johann
Sebastian Bach, who is not known to have visited Goa.Nonetheless, the
press release has been regurgitated on the front pages of the Deccan
Herald and the Indian Express and inside the Telegraph, citing Perus
Narkp, "the intelligence wing of the Berlin-based German Chancellor's
Core (sic)", as the source.

Perus Narkp, a not especially Germanic name, is an anagram of "Super Prank".

The organisation's motto, printed at the top of the press release, is
"Eht rea enp cabk skripc" — clearly not the language of Goethe or
Virgil, but another anagram: "The Pen Pricks are back".

The Pen Pricks, who run a blog skewering the Goan press, promised
readers on Sunday they were about to break a "big, Big, BIg, BIG"
story. It looks like they succeeded. Still, it should not take
pranksters to remind us that gullibility is a dangerous flaw in
journalism.

It takes Google only 0.13 seconds to establish that the Marsha Tikash
Whanaab concentration camp at which Bach was apparently posted does
not exist. The Express reporter, at least, telephoned the German
embassy and Indian police for comment. The fact they had no idea what
the reporter was talking about did not deter publication. Only the
Times of India gave even a hint that it smelt something fishy, but ran
a story all the same.

(I don't want to seem like I'm recklessly throwing stones in a glass
house: no organisation is immune to occasional lapses in journalistic
perfection, as readers of the Reuters' blog Good, Bad, and Ugly may be
aware.)

I asked Ramakrishna Upadhya, a senior editor at the Deccan Herald,
what might have gone wrong.

"We all believed that it was real because it had so many details," he
said about the press release. "They should have been cross-checked,"
he added.

He said he is investigating what happened, and that the paper will run
a correction if necessary.

An official at the German embassy in New Delhi very politely said they
were looking into what happened but considered it too soon to declare
it a hoax.

I have tried to e-mail the Pen Pricks. I'll let you know if I get any response.

Hopefully this was a singular blip and from now on we can once again
believe every word we read in the press.

ENDS